NYI 5–4 PIT Final / OT · W
Islanders/Schedule/Recap Tue, Feb 3, 2026 · 2025-26 regular season
New York Islanders
NYI · 31-21-5
5–4
Final / OTW
Pittsburgh Penguins
PIT · 28-15-12
1ST2ND3RDOTT NYI 210052711523 PIT 11121211200435 goals · shots on goal
Meeting 2 this season — the season series is tied 1–1
NYI 31-21-5 · PIT 28-15-12 · Meeting 2 this season — the season series is tied 1–1

Islanders beat the Penguins

The Islanders were outchanced (3.6 to 2.8 expected goals) but won it in overtime on Horvat's goal anyway. Stuart Skinner allowed 2.2 more goals than expected from the shots he faced.

Who had the better chances

The Penguins created the better chances: 3.6 expected goals to 2.8, on 35 and 23 shots on goal.

NYI 2.8 xG · 23 shots PIT 3.6 xG · 35 shots
0
1
2
3
4
1st 1.7 · 1.2
2nd · the swing 0.5 · 1.4
3rd 0.2 · 1.0
OT 0.3 · 0.0
Tap a numbered goal to see how it happened.
Deserve to winReplay this game 100 times with average goalies and the Islanders win 37.
NYI 37%PIT 63%

Goals and penalties

9 goals · 4 penalties
← Islanders shoot this way Penguins shoot this way →
On net Missed Bigger = better chance 1Goal, numbered to the list
1st period
PEN
01:54 Scott Mayfield· Hooking
Killed
2 min
Minor
1
Justin Brazeau · snap shot, a great chance (26%)
0–1
2
18:41 Bo Horvat
Anders Lee · backhand shot on a rebound, a great chance (69%)
1–1
3
19:56 Matthew Schaefer EXTRA ATTACKER
Ondrej Palat, Bo Horvat · slap shot, a low-percentage shot (5%) that found a way in
2–1
2nd period
4
Tommy Novak, Erik Karlsson · snap shot, a good chance (19%)
2–2
PEN
04:08 Erik Karlsson· Delaying game puck over glass
Killed
2 min
Minor
5
14:09 Bryan Rust
Sidney Crosby, Ilya Solovyov · wrist shot, a low-percentage shot (6%) that found a way in
2–3
PEN
18:07 Carson Soucy· Holding
Killed
2 min
Minor
3rd period
6
Adam Pelech · slap shot, a low-percentage shot (4%) that found a way in
3–3
7
Brett Kulak · tip in shot, a low-percentage shot (6%) that found a way in
3–4
PEN
11:52 Sidney Crosby· Tripping
Killed
2 min
Minor
8
15:24 Ryan Pulock
Mathew Barzal, Simon Holmstrom · snap shot, a low-percentage shot (6%) that found a way in
4–4
Overtime
9
00:52 Bo Horvat GWG
Mathew Barzal, Matthew Schaefer · snap shot, a great chance (32%)
5–4
Goaltending
−0.4
vs expected
31/35 saves · 4 GA · 3.6 xGA Gave up about what the shots he faced would predict.
−2.2
vs expected
18/23 saves · 5 GA · 2.8 xGA Allowed 2.2 more goals than expected from the shots he faced.
Team NYIPIT
Shots on goal
23
35
Expected goals
2.8
3.6
Hits
22
25
Blocks
11
14
Faceoffs
55%
45%
Power play
0/2
0/2
Penalty minutes
4
4
The Islanders went 0-for-2 on the power play and killed all 2 Penguins power plays.